Montreal: Ever-Increasing Taxes, But Where Are the Real Priorities?

Montreal: Ever-Increasing Taxes, But Where Are the Real Priorities?
I just read the announcement in La Presse: in 2027, local borough taxes in Montreal will jump by an average of 8.75%. In some areas, the pill is even harder to swallow: 14% in Rosemont–La Petite-Patrie, 12% in Verdun and Outremont, 11.5% in Le Plateau-Mont-Royal, and 9.2% in Ahuntsic–Cartierville.
Of course, this only applies to the local borough portion of the tax bill. But another statistic hits much harder: over the last ten years, Montrealers’ overall municipal tax bill has surged by an average of 44%.
The question becomes unavoidable: at what point do we stop dipping into taxpayers’ pockets and start doing some serious soul-searching about how this public money is actually managed?
Before Raising Taxes, Why Not Manage Better? Managing a major metropolis is a massive challenge—I get it. Infrastructure is aging, and construction costs are skyrocketing. But systematically passing the tab onto citizens isn’t inevitable. It’s a political choice. And when you dig into the reports from Montreal’s Auditor General, you find missteps that deserve serious scrutiny.
Take the organic waste treatment facilities. In 2013, Montreal planned to build five facilities for $237 million. By 2020, not a single facility was operational, the project was scaled back to just two plants, and the price tag neared double the original budget. Who is being held accountable for a gap like that?
Millions Lost in the Cracks of the Pavement We’ve all fumed after watching a freshly paved street get torn up again just a few months later. It’s not just a petty grievance—the Auditor General formally documented severe coordination issues across municipal worksites.
Worse yet, administrative blunders cost the City a grant worth nearly $11 million due to non-compliance with contract requirements. Eleven million dollars! Imagine what that money could have funded in infrastructure maintenance before asking property owners to fork over even more.
IT projects follow the same pattern. Modernizing city systems is essential, but platforms like SIMON swallow fortunes without ever proving clear productivity gains. A city shouldn’t measure its performance by how much money it spends, but by the tangible results it delivers.
Prioritizing Needs Over Wants This brings us to the core of the issue: city administration priorities. I have nothing against bike lanes—they have their place in a modern city. But governing means setting priorities.
When water mains are leaking, replacing lead service lines is dragging on, and homelessness is surging across our neighborhoods, are we investing in the right order? Before funding nice-to-have urban enhancements, we must fix the essential infrastructure under our feet.
This is precisely why certain political comments give me cold sweats. When I hear the mayor floated the idea of bringing the Olympic Games back to Montreal, frankly, it scares me. If we struggle to coordinate basic roadwork and our water lines are on the verge of failing, is this really the time to dream about a mega-event notorious for astronomical cost overruns? Montrealers have already paid the price for Olympic financial money pits. Before aiming for gold, let’s make sure our pipes aren’t leaking.
The Hidden Cost on Housing As a real estate professional, one blind spot in this debate worries me deeply: the direct impact of municipal taxation on the housing crisis.
People regularly denounce soaring rents, and rightly so. But the economic reality behind the brick walls is too often ignored. Operating a rental building is extremely expensive—property taxes, insurance, routine maintenance, repairs, and financing costs. When every expense goes up simultaneously, the financial strain becomes overwhelming.
A landlord cannot absorb these hikes indefinitely. Even though rent increases are regulated, skyrocketing operating costs stifle renovations, squeeze profitability, and ultimately weigh heavy on the rental market overall. Tenants and landlords shouldn’t be pitted against each other. They share a common interest: living in a city where housing costs remain sustainable.
Two Tax Payments a Year: An Outdated Rigidity Beyond grand policy shifts, there are immediate fixes. Why does Montreal stubbornly stick to demanding tax payments in just two massive installments, usually in March and June?
In an era where households are suffocating under financial pressures, receiving two multi-thousand-dollar bills in just a few months is brutal. Why not allow monthly installments over 12 months without extra fees, just like every other essential service? The City gets its revenue, while granting taxpayers flexibility and breathing room.
I care deeply about Montreal. Its potential is immense. But loving your city means demanding that it be managed responsibly. Before asking us for another dollar, the administration must prove it has learned from past mistakes, tightened its controls, and optimized every single cent already entrusted to it.
City money doesn’t grow on trees. It’s our money.
What do you think? Should Montreal clean up its administrative house and priorities before handing us the next bill?
An opinion piece by a concerned citizen and real estate professional invested in Montreal’s future.
Sources:
  • La Presse, “Taxes locales à Montréal — Un bond de près de 9 % en 2027,” October 19, 2026.
  • Office of the Auditor General of Montreal, Annual Reports 2020 & 2021.
  • City of Montreal, public documentation on municipal taxation and infrastructure.